EDIT 03/07/2008: Seems like the idea is not so unpopular after all. See this thread on gentoo.users mailing list
Edit 03/10/2008: Now there is a forum thread to discuss the idea. Thank you Dan
Gentoo is lacking man-power. If you ask any developer he/she will tell
you that more developers would be great to help finishing all the task
lying around. Where do you look if you want more developers? In the
community and users of course! Gentoo needs new and interesting ways
of involve more and more the users with the development process to
find users willing to go to the next level and become developers.
Ubuntu has this site called: "ubuntu brainstorm" where users can
propose ideas to be voted by other users and improve their ideas up to
a feasible level. I think that Gentoo could use
something like this. As with ubuntu's site we will be getting ideas
like "Push Logitech to make Linux software for theire harmony
remote controls". It's not a bad idea, but it's not something any
distro could do (after all is the user who buys from X who should push
for proper support, not the distro, because is the customer who was
the power do to so). As with any brainstorm you will get a mixed bag
of good and not so good ideas
Does this really help? I definitly think so. If the idea is good
enough and popular enough, the developers could push the original
reporter to create a more detailed view of the idea until you get a
"blueprint" feasible of implementantion. What happens next? Somebody
willing to help may step up, or even the proposer could try to
implement it... you get new, motivated people working.
This idea was proposed
as bug
212527 and Mike Doty's answer was WONTFIX:"we're
not ubuntu. We have plenty of places for users to provide input, this
isn't needed. nor do we have any source for it."
I know we are not ubuntu. Does it mean that we couldn't use any
idea from them for the sake of "not being ubuntu"? As with the "plenty
of places for user to provide input" I think Mike refers to mailing
lists, forums, irc channels and bugzilla. All this places are good
ways of input but none of them are specific for the task. What we get
from a special site is an easier and centralized way of dealing with
the ideas. This also mean that if an idea and a bug report are related
they should link each other.